A 69-year-old man has been jailed after he reportedly “terrified” a teen at a Cody grocery store last week by cornering her with profanity-laced stories and then following her as she tried to end …
This item is available in full to subscribers.
The Powell Tribune has expanded its online content. To continue reading, you will need to either log in to your subscriber account, or purchase a subscription.
If you are a current print subscriber, you can set up a free web account by clicking here.
If you already have a web account, but need to reset it, you can do so by clicking here.
If you would like to purchase a subscription click here.
Please log in to continue |
|
A 69-year-old man has been jailed after he reportedly “terrified” a teen at a Cody grocery store last week by cornering her with profanity-laced stories and then following her as she tried to end the conversation. Authorities say the Cody resident, John P. Cataldi, has done similar things to a half-dozen other females in the area.
At a Friday hearing, Park County Circuit Court Judge Joey Darrah ruled that Cataldi will need to post $10,000 to get out of jail while the case is pending. He remained in custody on Monday.
Cataldi faces a misdemeanor count of breach of peace and an allegation that he violated his probation from a similar, August incident on the North Fork.
“The pattern is just very concerning,” Deputy Park County Prosecuting Attorney Marina Tucker said in requesting the $10,000 bond.
For his part, Cataldi denied the allegations and unsuccessfully asked to be released on his own recognizance.
“The way it appears to me, I believe I am not guilty,” he said Friday.
Six minutes of talking
A sworn statement composed by Cody Police Officer Justin Dollard says the incident occurred around midday Wednesday at the Cody Albertsons. A 16-year-old Cody High School student reported that shortly after she entered the store, Cataldi approached her and began talking about her long hair. She said Cataldi then proceeded to talk about how he used to have long hair, a prior stint behind bars and music.
Over the course of the conversation, the girl said Cataldi used the f-word multiple times along with the n-word, according to Dollard’s summary of the girl’s account.
The teen reported that she told Cataldi she needed to get back to school and then pretended to field a phone call in an attempt to leave. However, she said Cataldi just kept talking and moved closer when she tried to back away, the officer’s summary says.
About six minutes into the conversation, an Albertsons employee saw Cataldi had cornered the girl and intervened, directing the student to the customer service counter; however, Cataldi continued to follow the teen, which scared her further, she told police.
As she began crying at the counter, Cataldi apologized for talking so much and left, the officer’s summary says.
The employee told police that Cataldi was a frequent customer who’d done the same type of thing to multiple people.
‘He intended to make her smile’
When police questioned Cataldi about the incident, he allegedly confirmed the key parts of the girl’s account. For instance, he reportedly admitted that his stories about Jimi Hendrix’s music included the profanities the teen described.
The officer’s affidavit says Cataldi offered explanations for his behavior — saying he’d gotten close to the girl because he can’t hear well and that he’d followed her to the customer service area because he wanted to apologize for taking up her time.
Cataldi also said he didn’t realize the teen was uncomfortable as he “intended to make her smile,” Dollard wrote.
However, charging documents say the girl was still crying, shaking and visibly upset when she later returned to school and spoke with police.
“Based on her appearance, behavior, and account of the incident, she appeared terrified by the encounter,” Dollard wrote.
While many breach of peace cases are handled as citations, Dollard said the six similar incidents that had already been documented by local law enforcement led him to believe that Cataldi “would likely engage in similar conduct toward another person if not immediately arrested.”
‘I just have one last statement’
During Friday’s hearing, Cataldi disregarded Judge Darrah’s advisements to remain silent and to avoid speaking about what happened at Albertsons.
“What I want to just tell you is that I have 16 years sober,” Cataldi told the judge, “and with that, the side effect of that is that I talk a lot — and Cody has turned out to be a wonderful place to meet people.”
As the defendant prepared to continue, Darrah cut him off. The judge said Cataldi had offered the same explanation for the earlier incident at a North Fork business.
“I’ve heard it, and … I understand what happened at Wapiti, and why you’re on probation,” Darrah said. “So we don’t need to hear that again.”
Cataldi replied that he just had “one last statement to make in regards to that,” but the judge said it wasn’t the time or place.
If Cataldi does post bond ahead of his April trial date, he’ll be barred from returning to Albertsons; Tucker indicated that Walmart has also banned Cataldi from its Cody store.