EDITORIAL: Divided GOP cannot stand for very long

Posted 3/11/14

“We must keep the door open — offering our party as the only practical answer for those who, overall, are individualists,” Reagan said in a 1967 speech, “And because this is the great common denominator — this dedication to the belief in …

This item is available in full to subscribers.

Please log in to continue

E-mail
Password
Log in

EDITORIAL: Divided GOP cannot stand for very long

Posted

Ronald Reagan led the Republican Party to political dominance by espousing a “big tent” philosophy.

“We must keep the door open — offering our party as the only practical answer for those who, overall, are individualists,” Reagan said in a 1967 speech, “And because this is the great common denominator — this dedication to the belief in man’s aspirations as an individual — we cannot offer them a narrow sectarian party in which all must swear allegiance to prescribed commandments.

“The Republican Party, both in this state and nationally, is a broad party,” he said in the speech, delivered in his first year as California’s governor, 13 years before he won the first of two terms as president. “There is room in our tent for many views; indeed, the divergence of views is one of our strengths.”

The internal battles of the Republican Party, in Park County, in Wyoming and across the country, indicate to us that more members of the GOP need to recall Reagan’s words, especially if they want to succeed in politics and government.

On March 3, the Park County Republican Party had a very public dispute. It was based on who was a “real” Republican and who was one in name only. Some party members tried to remove Bob Berry of Cody from the county executive committee. The effort failed, 16-25.

Terry Hinkle said he believes Berry is more committed to the tea party movement, and the Big Horn Basin TEA Party, than he is to the Republican Party. Hinkle pointed out that Berry is an outspoken critic of a prominent Park County Republican, state Sen. Hank Coe. Of course, Hinkle is a very public Coe supporter and has served as his campaign manager.

It does seem odd that a member of the party’s inner circle is an advocate for Coe’s defeat or removal from office. But Berry feels Coe is too linked to big government, and also betrayed the party when he sponsored a bill in the 2013 session to strip Cindy Hill, the superintendent of public instruction, of much of her authority.

Hill, like everyone else in this scrape, is a Republican. She was a featured speaker at the Big Horn Basin TEA Party picnic last summer, and she has a lot of support in this corner of the state.

Of course, so does Coe. He defeated Berry twice in 2012, once in the GOP primary and a second time in the general election when Berry ran as a write-in candidate.

The executive committee should represent a diversity of viewpoints. Coe has been a leader in county and state politics for several years. It seems strange that he has become such a target in his own backyard, especially since he and Berry undoubtedly agree more than they differ on issues big and small.

It’s a local sign of the internal battle for the soul of the Republican Party across the country, with tea party members trying to seize control and push the party further to the right, and more traditional mainstream party members seeking to maintain their grip on the party’s machinery.

There are other examples of the GOP family feud.

Same-sex marriage is a prominent topic today, and while there are strong advocates and equally determined opponents, one thing is clear: Gay unions are becoming more and more accepted in the United States.

On March 4, a friend of the court brief signed by 20 Republicans, led by former Sen. Alan Simpson of Cody and former Sen. Nancy Kassebaum of Kansas, as well as other prominent party members, was submitted to a federal appeals court in Denver that is reviewing the same-sex marriage bans in Utah and Oklahoma. Among the signers is former Republican National Committee chairman Kenneth Mehlman, who came out of the closet in 2010.

The group quoted Reagan and another conservative icon, Barry Goldwater, the longtime Arizona senator and 1964 Republican presidential candidate, in its brief.

It quoted a passage from his 1960 book “The Conscience of a Conservative” to make its point: “For the American Conservative, there is no difficulty in identifying the day’s overriding political challenge: it is to preserve and extend freedom,” Goldwater wrote. “As he surveys the various attitudes and institutions and laws that currently prevail in America, many questions will occur to him, but the Conservative’s first concern will always be: Are we maximizing freedom?”

Does that include the freedom to love and live with the person of your choice? Republicans are very sensitive to homosexual-themed issues, as we witnessed during the brief contest between Sen. Mike Enzi and challenger Liz Cheney, when gay marriage was a hot potato.

Families, and political parties, are going to have squabbles. That’s to be expected, and there are some benefits to it as well. A healthy debate allows all sides to be heard.

People, parties and nations must grow and adapt to survive. The GOP has lost the popular vote in five of the last six presidential elections. The sooner Republicans accept that, the better their chances to have a more influential voice in the nation’s business and not just in some states and congressional districts.

The College Republican National Committee has just released a report indicating that millions of young Americans have serious doubts about the GOP and its policies. The report calls for a new focus for the party based on its old standards.

“On the ‘open-minded’ issue, yes, we will face serious difficulty so long as the issue of gay marriage remains on the table,” the authors of the report wrote. “In the short term, the party ought to promote the diversity of thought within its ranks and make clear that we welcome healthy debate on the policy topic at hand.”

Republican Party members should heed the words of the party’s first president, Abraham Lincoln, whose immortal words in an 1858 speech ring true today: “A house divided against itself cannot stand.”

Comments